Thursday, February 24, 2011

Who Would You Rather Have?

An average player on a good team or a good player on a bad team?

This weeks argument is Brett Gardner vs. Ichiro Suzuki


Why Brett Gardner:


Why Not Brett Gardner:

  • Yankees are loaded with veteran outfielders and since Brett does not have the stick they do, DH is not really an option for him.
  • He is starting in LF but Andruw Jones will see a lot of playing time against lefties be it for Granderson or Gardner.
  • He hits in the bottom of the lineup and behind slower runners so his double with a man on first might not net an RBI.

Why Ichiro Suzuki:

  • Pretty much a lock for 200 hits.
  • Ichiro will see more AB in a season which gives him a greater chance to produce.
  • ...This is Ichiro we are talking about.

Why Not Ichiro Suzuki:

  • Will turn 37 this season and is no longer a threat to hit .350.
  • The lineup behind him is not that good and Ichiro needs to score runs to retain his value. 

So who would you rather have?
Click to Show Comments

Recent Posts

MLB NBA NFL

Follow Us on Twitter!