Buster Posey finished with 874.8 points in 2015, the 57th best season by a catcher in fantasy baseball.  In 2012, Posey finished with 1023.3 points, the 10th best from a catcher since 1970.


But compared to the All-Time great seasons (since 1970) no one has done what Hall of Famer Mike Piazza did 1997 - posting 1200+ points!  Only 2009 Joe Mauer and 1999 Piazza have ever even reached 1100 points!  Ivan Rodriguez is the only other catcher to make the list twice.


SeasonNameTeamABH2B3BHRBBHBPSBCSPoints
1997Mike PiazzaDodgers55620132140693511266.8
2009Joe MauerTwins52319130128762411141.3
1996Mike PiazzaDodgers54718416036811031105.8
1970Johnny BenchReds60517735445540521099.4
1970Joe TorreCardinals62420327921707221069
1998Mike Piazza- - -56118438132582101068
1974Johnny BenchReds62117438233803541032.5
1979Darrell PorterRoyals5331552310201218341028.2
1972Johnny BenchReds538145222401002661025.8
2012Buster PoseyGiants53017839124692111023.3
1999Ivan RodriguezRangers6001992913524125121022.1
2000Jorge PosadaYankees505145351281078221020.6
2007Jorge PosadaYankees50617142120746201010.9
2000Mike PiazzaMets48215626038583421009.2
2000Jason KendallPirates57918533614791522121008.7
2003Javy LopezBraves4571502934333401996.6
1977Carlton FiskRed Sox5361692632675976995.8
1970Dick DietzGiants49314836222109301991.6
2006Joe MauerTwins5211813641379183988.8
1993Mike PiazzaDodgers5471742423546334978.9
1999Mike PiazzaMets5341622504051122975.9
1982Gary CarterExpos5571633212978625968.7
1996Todd HundleyMets5401403214179313967.4
2001Mike PiazzaMets5031512903667202966.5
1975Ted SimmonsCardinals5811933231863113964.4
2009Victor Martinez- - -5881783312375310962.3
1998Jason KendallPirates535175363125131265960.7
2007Victor MartinezIndians56216940025621000951.4

How Fantasy Points Are Calculated:

  • AB - (-1)
  • H - 5.6
  • 2B - 2.9
  • 3B - 5.7
  • HR - 9.4
  • BB - 3
  • HBP - 3
  • SB - 1.9
  • CS - (-2.8)